Are YouTube’s New Comment Moderation Tools Enough?

Are YouTube’s New Comment Moderation Tools Enough?

It’s a common rule for most users on the internet: businesses and content creators can’t turn a blind eye to consumer engagement—in fact, a well-managed brand would say that comments are a valuable resource, as you can learn a lot from your fans and consumers from them. Thankfully, YouTube recently unveiled new tools to help users of all types can moderate comments on their channels so they can make the most of the discussions that center around their content.

The biggest change YouTube implemented is how content creators can engage with their fans. Arguably the most useful new feature is the ability to pin comments: creators can now float especially informative or appreciated comments to the top of the feed, encouraging good, useful responses to videos. As a content creator, you can pin your own comment, too.

A great way to shape the conversation around your video is to provide a conversation topic or discussion question in a comment pinned to the top of the feed. These calls to action are typically included in video descriptions—but by putting them in a pinned comment, you ensure your viewers will see them before they are compelled to post. Thus, you’re able to better shape the conversation’s direction and keep things on-topic.

YouTubers may also award hearts—essentially, “like” in typical social media parlance—posts left from viewers.  This is an incredibly easy way to respond to good responses and show appreciation for fans. While creator hearts might encourage more attention-begging from fans, this new system—in concert with YouTube’s already-existing comment voting system and pinning feature discussed above—should overall encourage the conversation to remain informative and respectful.

In addition to the announcement of new features, YouTube also reminded users of the platform’s existing comment moderation tools, such as the ability to choose other users to help moderate. While other features such as keyword blacklisting and auto-censoring inappropriate comments are useful, they are imperfect solutions; the auto-censoring, for example, is only a beta feature with kinks to be worked out.

The biggest issue with native keyword blacklisting and auto-censoring is that you can’t manage the comments in realtime if they’re not on your list. Not to mention how limited keyword blacklisting is: trolls and spam bots can easily change spacing and spelling to bypass such systems. Furthermore, comments that are caught don’t go away; instead, they’re held for review and you, the user, must check to ensure there aren’t any false-positives. This means that if you’re a target of harassment, your viewers won’t see the comments YouTube catches—but you’ll still have to face the abuse when looking them over.

This isn’t to say YouTube isn’t making huge steps in the right direction when it comes to comment moderation. The new features are great! But users who find that the native tools are a little lacking might want to try third-party software to supplement them. Smart Moderation is similar to YouTube’s auto-censoring and blacklisting tools, but there’s a key difference: it’s a dynamic tool powered by artificial intelligence that erases abusive and spam comments within the minute they’re posted. It’s not limited to rigid keywords to know what’s inappropriate; instead, it can read the context and learn just as a human would.

Pinned comments and creator hearts can incentivize fans to keep discussion clean and on-topic, but Smart Moderation will easily detect and remove comments left by trolls, haters and spammers. You can even try it out for free to see how well it works for you compared to using just first-party tools.

Here’s our question to you: Are you excited by the new features? How do you intend to use them on your YouTube profile?


  1. Bonsoir Niao,Merci de ta visite sur le blog.Ecris si tu veux, au moins tu as des idées ! … du moment que tu respectes l’oeuvre initiale de J.K. Rowling… bref tu nous tiens au courant, je suis intéressé de lire « un jeune cancre qui aime rêver ».Quant au septième tome, laissons l’auteur l’écrire. On verra bien à sa sortie…

  2. Sir I am karikalan Doing All Type of Used metal Scraps Buyers & Sellers,papers,petbottle, Commission Agent.If You Need Anything Indian to export /Import Please Contact Me.My E-Mail: I am Living mauritius

  3. I’m 27 Years of age and full time student (CA. 30 SWS) . In addition to my studies I’m part-time self-employed, for this I turn a week about 7 Hours on. By the secondary I have income per month by an average of 200 Euro.I can however as a student health disclosed me?Thank you for the information.

  4. I think they are all nice, but the bath salts feels the most practical, and I love that it ties in with your theme. Plus if you have left over mason jars you can decorate with them at the wedding. Do it yourself gifts are always better in my opinion. I'm excited to read a lot more wedding posts from you in the new year! 🙂

  5. Talvipyöräilyä varten on myös nastarenkaat, joita saa alan liikkeistä ja isoimmista marketeista. Eivätkä ole kovin kalliitakaan. Kannattaa ehdottomasti hankkia, on pitoa ihan jäälläkin.Pyöräilen aina kypärä päässä, mutta ongelmana on sen säilytys. Jos vaikka pyöräilee asemalle, niin minnekäs jätät kypärän? Ei sitä ole mukava ottaa mukaan junaan ja töihinkään. Tässä olisi päättäjillä/suunnittelijoilla mietittävää kun pyöräilyä halutaan lisätä.Ja jos uutta kypärää tarvitsee, kannattaa katsoa Saksan valikoimat. Tavara tullut edullisesti ja

  6. Just want to say your article is as surprising. The clearness to your publish is simply cool and i could suppose you are an expert on this subject. Fine together with your permission let me to clutch your feed to stay up to date with forthcoming post. Thank you 1,000,000 and please keep up the gratifying work.

  7. Hi, Kira:Thanks for asking, but we at ZO Skin Health are separate from the company that makes Obagi Nu-Derm (Obagi Medical Products), and therefore do not represent their products or regimen. Dr. Obagi was a founder of both companies, but no longer is associated with Obagi Medical Products. I therefore suggest that you speak with a physician or other skincare professional for medical advice.Thanks for asking; I am sorry that I cannot be of more assistance.Donna QueenDonna Queen

  8. En esta serie me gusta especialmente esa “pequeña” complicidad que has logrado captar entre madre e hija.Se debían encontrar agusto, pues se percibe mucha espontaneidad.Muy buen trabajo Roy.Lupe Bicos.

  9. I totally agree with both of you. Lung cancer is one on the worst, except for pancreatic cancer becasue you can’t get a translpant with that one. My grandpa had half a lung removed from smoking 4 packs of non-filtered cigarettes a day. He still lived, although he was on a nebulizer and oxygen most of the time. The sad part is……. I still smoke.

  10. I don’t think many people would argue that, if implemented properly, Semantic Search will make life easier for people trawling for information; there’s a reason that the giants of the industry are so enthusiastic. The $64,000 question is how it is going to be implemented; to which I think you’re completely accurate in saying that we simply do not know, and anyone who claims otherwise is wrong. The change is inevitable; Google want it, Bing want it, it’s happening. All we can really do is sit back, cross our fingers and see what happens.

  11. « Qu’ appelez-vous le copinage d’Etat ? »Un ministre mécène, avec nos sous, de la culture et ses courtisans du spectacle vivant pour les uns, en déjeuner en Ville. Comme s’il existait un spectacle mort pour les autres et depuis quand, l’antiquité aristotélicienne peut être? comme si tous les villages de France allaient au théatre ce soir profiter du spectacle de leurs impots.Pourquoi pas un ministère de la vérité vraie tant qu’a faire.

  12. I’ve had trouble with JustHost in 1.5 months after I signed up with them. They say everything is unlimited but if you use just a little bit more server resources they’ll tell you they can’t host you anymore.

  13. Hur känns det med Botoxen o Restylanet? Hoppas verkligen du svarar, för du väcker ju frågan med stora inlägg, och får oss andra att undra en del. Botox har jag själv gjort, men inte Restylanet. Väntar på svar! =)Kram/ Maja

  14. I used to be CONVINCED that I could predict what posts people would resonate with, and which ones they wouldn’t. And I discovered that I’m REALLY BAD and predicting this. Often times, it’s the most unlikely ones that people gravitate the most towards, for some mysterious reason. So, yes, you are better off writing about what resonates with YOU and hope that people like it, too. At the end of the day, this should be FUN!

  15. Really Ben? I guess when we speak those truest words from deep within our hearts, those who do not resonate with our story may need to leave our lives. Although I am likely waxing philosophical when you were likely sharing your wit (or would that be waxing witty?) That’s what I do. Thanks for visiting this older post of mine!

  16. Dans un monde ou tout se monnaye, le meilleur comme le pire, elle est dans la norme. Évidemment avec son créneau : vous ne voudriez pas qu’a 81 ans elle gagne du pognon en montrant ses …. dans une emission de téléréalité ! Bref tout cela est obscène comme notre époque

  17. I loved as much as you will receive performed right here. The cartoon is tasteful, your authored subject matter stylish. nonetheless, you command get got an impatience over that you wish be handing over the following. ill definitely come more until now again since exactly the similar just about a lot incessantly within case you shield this increase.

  18. Hello There. I found your weblog the usage of msn. This is an extremely well written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and come back to learn extra of your helpful information. Thank you for the post. I’ll definitely comeback.

  19. Would be interested to see what recent research is currently being undertaken. Yes we see them down here. On a number of occasions they find something on my dive gear that they get fixated on and end up following me around for the whole dive. Very inquisitive. Always a good dive when you see these beauties.

  20. Glad you enjoyed your stay there! My husband’s grandfather owns some property there, and he has two uncles who live in the Keys (one who is an artist) because of the reasons you cite. It’s a really neat place. I’m glad to hear you had a great vacation!

  21. The part and piece about narrowing one’s focus and tagging and branding – is one that gets me – too – into a panic. I’m trying to figure the whole thing out – what attracts and what doesn’t..but – in the meanwhile – am having fun being creative.[]

  22. I don’t breathe during landings either. I’m not sure because it’s been a while since I’ve flown but I probably close my eyes as well.Planes into SFO come in over water. I don’t want to see it if it’s all the same to everyone.

  23. Does it come as a surprise to anyone that when asked to provide a report that will be used to justify their own continued existence they produce one that shows leaving power with them to be the only logical choice? Let’s have an independent third party NOT CONTRACTED BY LIPA look at the situation. Otherwise we’re asking the cat if we should leave it alone with the bird.

  24. Jag är så nyfiken på om ni nu skulle bygga nytt hus, vad skulle du då bygga för typ av hus?? Något som du gärna vill att huset ska ha?? Precis som de flesta andra som läser din blogg så tycker jag att den är super!!!Kramar Linda

  25. The Oil companies are trying their best to stop free energy thoughts from spreading to common ppl.We need to place an end to this corruption ,start generating your own electricity now.Visit LT-MAGNET-MOTORdotCOM and get the blueprints . Join the Revolution!!

  26. You attempt to love them and they repeatedly are rude, disrespectful, and hurtfulAnd they are aware of what they are doing and do not wish to change?Divorce in my opinion of biblical scripture is not an option for loving one’s wife/husband is a commandHow is this reconciled? Does God reconcile this or is it because the person chose their spouse this is the situation that they will have to deal with?I think often about Hosea and GomerWhat is scripture regarding this manner?

  27. 10aUff y yo que llevo ya tres años con el sofón y sólo lo he usado en un taller de espumas al que fui, soy un desastre. A ver si me animo porque me encanta pero luego me da pereza, no lo entiendo… La foto te ha quedado estupenda, realmente magnífica!!15b

  28. Det glemte jeg.. ja , du kan sikkert støpe i lokk. Tror det er en fordel med plast, så du kan bøye og bende litt på det for å få ut betongen. Ellers kjøpte jeg min form på Panduro. Den er ment til å støpe hageheller i:)

  29. OLGA MARINESCU spune:Doamne ajuta! Eu cred ca cea mai scurta cale de a ajunge prieten al lui Dumnezeu, este sa ne dorim sa fim buni. Blagosloviti si ma iertati!

  30. dit :I experimented with looking at your blog on my iphone and the page layout doesnt seem to be correct. Might want to check it out on WAP as well as it seems most cell phone layouts are not working with your web site.

  31. – it would be great if there was a bit more transparency i.e. a signal/flag to indicate that speeds are having an effect (or not).e.g. one of my system customers has a page of their 50 newest sets of photos (they're an image library) – they could reduce this to say 25 to increase load speed – but then they would be loosing some functionality in a way – presenting new products to paying customers. Need to find a balance.What is the speed issues cutoff ?

  32. sir, I am a final year bsc physics student.i want to do msc in physics.i want to be a civil servant.i need your advice about in which year i may be able to write the exam,which optionals may be suitable for me?is and sociology combination allowed?

  33. I can’t thank you fully for the articles on your site. I know you’d put a lot of time and effort into all of them and hope you know how much I enjoy it. I hope I can do the same person one of these days.

  34. Hej Lonse,Der er desværre ikke sÃ¥ meget andet, du kan erstatte det med. Prøv at give bønnerne og linserne en chance – jeg kunne faktisk heller ikke sÃ¥ godt lide dem, da jeg startede. Du kan fÃ¥ mange forskellige slags bønner med forskellig konsistens og smag. Mht linserne, sÃ¥ kan jeg anbefale de røde linser, som du kan koge meget ud og evt blende bagefter. Flere her pÃ¥ siden har ogsÃ¥ anbefalet at bruge en masse krydderier dertil, sÃ¥ de smager bedre.Hilsen Sanne

  35. Je serais intéressée par vos formations afin de pouvoir continuer à former, éduquer et aider des enfants en difficultés comme je le fais actuellement en qualité d’ancienne enseignante et même de pouvoir créer mon propre cours. Merci d’avance de vos conseils,vos renseignements et surtout le coût de tout votre matériel, votre formation.H RAYNAUD

  36. Growing Healthy Asian American Churches, 3Our blog-based book discussion of Growing Healthy Asian American Churches is off to a great start! Even though you do not have to have the book to comment, you are encouraged to buy the book to participate in this discussion more deeply and richly.Now…

  37. Thanks for that marvelous publishing! I undoubtedly enjoyed reading it, you are actually a great author. I will ensure that I bookmark your blog and probably will come back from now on. I desire to encourage anyone continue the great creating, have a pleasant morning!

  38. Czeczen pisze:Rowerem można przejechać dużo więcej niż 50 km. Preferuję jazdę offroadową (najprawdopodobniej takie będą warunki ewakuacji) i w maju zeszłego roku zrobiłem 100-110 km z odpoczynkiem, podejściami przez niewygodne odcinki, przedzieranie się przez zarośla, wąwozy i ogółem asfaltem jechałem może 45 km. Trasa zajęła mi około 11-12h z czego czas w ruchu wynosił 7-8h.Rower daje wiele możliwości, tylko trzeba poznać swoje umiejętności.

  39. Oh what a perfect party dress, you look so very beautiful and I just love the flower in your hair. Happiness is a great night of drinks with friends.Oh and a great new dress!!!!!!Love V


  41. Es gibt auch Zeugenaussagen, wonach die Person, die am Tattag das Wohnmobil verließ, eine Frau war.Es gibt auch Zeugenaussagen, wonach drei statt nur zwei Personen diesen Banküberfall begangen haben.Es gibt auch DNS-Spuren, die auf eine vierte Person im engsten Umkreis hindeuten bzw dieses beweisen.Die offizielle Version der Ereignisse hat demzufolge noch ein paar Schwachstellen, um es mal nett zu formulieren.

  42. Hallo und danke für den tol­len Bericht.Ich möchte mir auch einen Kindle zule­gen nur frag ich mich was mit den Bildern in PDFs pas­siert. Beispiel: Da es immer mehr Spiele vom Hersteller als Downloadversion gibt(oft bil­li­ger) sind die Handbücher nur als PDF vor­han­den. Allerdings ist es da nicht unüb­lich, dass es z.B. eine Hintergrundgrafik neben Screenshoots etc. gib aus­ge­legt ist das ganze dann oft auf A4.Irgendwelche Erfahrungen mit so was? Bilder?Grüße

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *